Vitamin D and HDL

Despite the paucity of scientific documentation of this phenomenon, I am continuing to witness extraordinary increases in HDL cholesterol levels with vitamin D supplementation.

I've touched on the interaction of vitamin D supplementation with HDL in The Heart Scan Blog previously:

Vitamin D: Treatment for metabolic syndrome?

HDL for Dummies


At first, I thought it was attributable to other factors. In real life, most people don't modify one factor at a time. They reduce
processed carbohydrates/eliminate wheat and cornstarch, lose weight, add or increase omega-3 fatty acids from fish oil, begin niacin, increase exercise and physical activity. All these efforts also impact on HDL.

Among the many things I do, I consult on complex lipid (cholesterol) disorders (complex hyperlipidemias) in my office. A substantial number of these people carry a diagnosis of hypoalphalipoproteinemia, a mouthful that simply means these people are unable to manufacture much apoprotein A1, the principal protein of HDL cholesterol particles. As a result, people with hypoalphalipoproteinemia have HDL cholesterol levels in the neighborhood of 20-30 mg/dl--very low. They are also at high risk for heart disease and stroke.

Encourage these people to exercise, attain ideal weight, eliminate wheat and cornstarch: HDL increases 5 mg/dl or so.

Add niacin, HDL increases another 5-10 mg/dl.

Perhaps we're now sitting somewhere around an HDL of 35-40 mg/dl--better, but hardly great.

Add vitamin D to achieve our target serum level . . . HDL jumps to 50, 60, 70, even 90 mg/dl.

The first few times this occurred, I thought it was an error or fluke. But now that I've witnessed this effect many dozens of time, I am convinced that it is real. Just today, I saw a 40-year old man whose starting HDL was 25 mg/dl increase to 87 mg/dl.

Responses like this are supposed to be impossible. Before vitamin D, I had never witnessed increases of this magnitude.

Not all therapies for raising HDL raise the important large (also known as HDL2b) fraction. With lipoprotein analyses, it appears that is principally the large fraction of HDL that rises with vitamin D supplementation.

Why? How?

That I can't tell you. But for those of you struggling with low HDL cholesterols despite your best efforts, vitamin D can make a world of difference.

An interesting corollary: If super-high HDL cholesterols are associated with extreme longevity, as they are with centenarians, does raising HDL to extraordinary levels with vitamin D lead to longer, healthier life, all the way up to age 110 years?

Again, no answers, but an interesting thought. And one I'd bet on. (And I'm not selling vitamin D.)

Comments (23) -

  • Stargazey

    8/19/2008 3:31:00 AM |

    If you don't mind, how much Vitamin D do these people take? Do they take it in divided doses or all at once?

  • arnoud

    8/19/2008 4:33:00 AM |

    Dr. Davis, very exciting info!  
    Could you comment on the typical time lag seen in improved HDL as a response to vitamin D supplementation?

  • Anonymous

    8/19/2008 11:34:00 AM |

    How do your observations jive with research showing that vitamin D inhibits apo-A1, which appears to confer greater protection against heart disease than HDL?

    Wehmeier K, Beers A, Haas MJ, Wong NC, Steinmeyer A, Zugel U, Mooradian AD (2005). "Inhibition of apolipoprotein AI gene expression by 1, 25-dihydroxyvitamin D3". Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1737 (1): 16–26. PMID 16236546.

  • Missbossy

    8/19/2008 11:35:00 AM |

    You might not be selling vitamin D... but these guys are!

    For Vitamin D, Drink Schlitz!

    Perhaps you could work this into your daily vitamin protocol...

  • Shreela

    8/19/2008 12:48:00 PM |

    I just noticed that I've been taking a Vit D and fish oil gel cap every time I read one of your posts about them, to make up for my 'forget' days 8^)

  • Stephan

    8/19/2008 4:26:00 PM |

    Just wanted to say thanks for your observations, that's very interesting.  Maybe someone will catch on and do a clinical trial.  Perhaps vitamin D will be the long-awaited HDL-raiser.  

    Hopefully some drug company will create an analog they can patent.  Just kidding.

  • Anonymous

    8/20/2008 12:41:00 AM |

    Because I have high LP(a)I take Niacin,exercise,mostly lean meats and veg/fruit diet. I have kept acurate blood draw records since 2002.Starting HDL was 50,had risen to mid 60's by 2007. Added 2000mg Vitamin D oil base gel caps 07 and 08. Last blood draw HDL was 85. I know it worked for me. It had no affect on LP(a)unfortunately remaining at 30 - 40. Thanks Dr Davis for making this known on your blog, it should help many.

  • The Girl

    8/20/2008 2:48:00 AM |

    I have HDL of 103, how common is this? I can't find much information about HDL levels this high...

  • Anonymous

    8/20/2008 12:07:00 PM |

    Missbossy -- funny! Yeah, a comedian (?) used to joke that he took vitamins with his beer so that while he was tearing himself down he was also building himself up. Smile

    I have been taking 6000 units Vit D3 daily to achieve measured blood vitamin D level (25-OH-vitamin D3) of 60 ng/ml.  Your mileage may vary.

  • Stuart Buck

    8/20/2008 2:23:00 PM |

    What about getting some sunshine?  Does that work?

  • Anonymous

    8/20/2008 3:13:00 PM |

    I'm also interested in your response regarding  vitamin D inhibiting apo-A1. It appears contrary to improved HDL.

    In my own case, vitamin D hasn't done anything for my HDL. I started with a D level at 21 and my HDL has hovered in the 27-34 range. Raised my D levels to 54, and my HDL sunk near the low point of 27

    I also had my Apo A1 tested separately, but my doctor isn't entirely sure how to read the data. My Apo A1 is in the reference range provided by the lab, although a bit towards the lower end. I have no way in determining if it's truly decent or not though.

  • Anonymous

    8/21/2008 2:19:00 PM |

    I started with a "D" level of 17 and an HDL of 63, started taking "D" supplements and raised my "D" level to exactly 60 and my HDL went down to 56.

  • Anonymous

    8/22/2008 2:27:00 AM |

    I too started with a low HDL of 35, added Vitamin D3, 3-4,000iu/daily and my HDL went to 71! I am a firm believer of Vitamin D>

  • Anonymous

    10/20/2008 7:44:00 AM |

    I'd like too see a reference to published research linking D3 supplementation to greater HDL.  I think D3 does have anti-atherosclerotic properties - despite what it does at a high dose.  When high doses are given to animals on a high fat diet, vitamin D3 actually induces atherosclerosis.  This is a common model for atherosclerosis in the lab which might account for why so many doctors seem to have missed the clinical benefits for D3 in heart disease.  Since D3 induces self-tolerance (partly via IL-10) and atherosclerosis has recently been described as an autoimmune condition caused by underfunctional regulatory T-cells, at a normal dose D3 probably has a protective effect against atherosclerosis.

  • Avon

    6/4/2009 7:11:31 PM |

    I would appreciate if anyone can help answer as to what is the daily dosage(in I.U's) of Vitamin D required to have an effect on raising the HDL number?

  • Anonymous

    9/10/2009 5:29:02 PM |

    I was actually trying to google why my HDL is so high and what it means (110 and double checked two years in a row), my LDL is 68.  I'm 47, walk 2.5 miles 4 or 5 days a week but other then that not sure what I'm doing.  I take a womens one a day vitamin and a caltrate.

  • Helene

    4/4/2010 6:15:35 PM |

    I found this web site because I was looking for an explanation why my HDL level jumped to 115 from a 2-year earlier level of 97.  My diet is the same, year round.  The only thing different is the increased amount of vitamin D (1400 IU/daily).  I have been diagnosed with osteopenia and the doctor suggested increasing my calcium and vitamin D intake. Conversely, my LDL is 79.

    Helene

  • RufusG

    8/27/2010 8:34:36 AM |

    Lack of exposure to sunlight, and therefore lack of Vitamin D, is implicated in over 60 illnesses.
    - including Heart health

    More at:

    www.grassrootshealth.net
    www.vitamindcouncil.org
    www.vitamindwiki.com
    www.vitamindandcholesterol.com

    I have posted a Personal Action Plan that explains testing and dose size at:

    www.rufusgreenbaum.com
    - see Downloads

    .

  • buy jeans

    11/3/2010 2:26:25 PM |

    The first few times this occurred, I thought it was an error or fluke. But now that I've witnessed this effect many dozens of time, I am convinced that it is real. Just today, I saw a 40-year old man whose starting HDL was 25 mg/dl increase to 87 mg/dl.

  • mobani

    12/11/2011 5:21:36 PM |

    I have ahistory of consistently lower HDL, around 30. In my recent blood test, it is idicated that my Vit D level is also low (22.6 ng/ml). I have been taking D-3 2000 IU. I n reecnt months  may have taken it irregularly. A month ago, I had the blood test and the same old results. I am not sure if I took D-3 daily. I will start taking it regularly for two months and do the test again. Do I need to raise the dose to 4000 IU instead of 2000/day? I jog every other day for 40 minutes. Diet consists of very low fat, and also take fish oil caaplets daily.
    My reecnt blood test results:
    Fasting cholesterol = 152 mg/dL
    HDL cholesterol = 32 (L)
    LDL cholesterol = 84
    Total Cholesterol / HDL ratio = 4.8 Cool
    TGL = 180 Cool
    Non-HDL cholesterol = 120

    I also have a throat problem. I do get clear mucus secretion in throat abnormally. Constantly spit out. Allergy medicine helps a bit but does not go away. I do not know if these three problems have  a common root. Any suggestions??? Appreciate your help.

  • mobani

    12/11/2011 5:33:32 PM |

    Interesting! How is this going now? I am looking for a solution like that. My posting added to the blog today is as follows:
    mobani says:

    December 11, 2011 at 11:21 pm


    I have ahistory of consistently lower HDL, around 30. In my recent blood test, it is idicated that my Vit D level is also low (22.6 ng/ml). I have been taking D-3 2000 IU. I n reecnt months may have taken it irregularly. A month ago, I had the blood test and the same old results. I am not sure if I took D-3 daily. I will start taking it regularly for two months and do the test again. Do I need to raise the dose to 4000 IU instead of 2000/day? I jog every other day for 40 minutes. Diet consists of very low fat, and also take fish oil caaplets daily.
    My reecnt blood test results:
    Fasting cholesterol = 152 mg/dL
    HDL cholesterol = 32 (L)
    LDL cholesterol = 84
    Total Cholesterol / HDL ratio = 4.8 Cool
    TGL = 180 Cool
    Non-HDL cholesterol = 120

    I also have a throat problem. I do get clear mucus secretion in throat abnormally. Constantly spit out. Allergy medicine helps a bit but does not go away. I do not know if these three problems have a common root. Any suggestions??? Appreciate your help.

  • Dr. William Davis

    12/14/2011 2:51:04 AM |

    Please read the vitamin D posts here, Mobani, and you will see that we achieve 25-hydroxy vitamin D levels of 60-70 ng/ml. Then wait about two years and HDL generally shows its full rise.

  • John Cross

    11/13/2013 5:22:19 AM |

    You may have reflux; 20% of reflux suffers don't get heartburn; feels like congestion. I know, I'm one of the 20%.

Loading
Success--Slow but sure

Success--Slow but sure

John is a gentleman.

At age 76, he continues to teach at a local college. He's a delight to talk to, having written several scholarly books on religious topics. He's a fountain of knowledge on religious history and the roots of faith.

John is one of those incurably optimistic people, always greeting me with a smile and a warm handshake. I can't help but linger for a hour or so to talk with John, unfortunately disrupting my office schedule miserably.

John is another Track Your Plaque success story. Though he didn't set any records in reduction of his heart scan score, he did it simply by adhering to the program over a period of two years, succeeding slowly but surely.

John's first heart scan score: 1190, a score that carries as much as a 25% annual risk for heart attack. Among the list of causes was an LDL cholesterol in the 170 mg/dl range, along with an LDL particle number that verified the accuracy of LDL.

Among John's suggested treatments was a statin drug, since I was not confident he could reduce LDL with diet and nutritional modifications sufficiently to safely reduce both LDL and his risk for heart attack. But he proved terribly intolerant to any dose of any statin, with incapacitating and strange side-effects, like head-to-toe itching, abdominal cramps and diarrhea. It was clear: John needed to do the program without benefit of a statin drug.

I therefore asked John to maximize all efforts that reduce LDL, 70% of which were small LDL paricles despite his very slender build. He used oat bran and ground flaxseed daily, raw nuts, a soy protein smoothie every morning, and eliminated wheat and other high-glycemic index foods (including the Oreos he loved to snack on). Because the mis-adventures with statin drugs wasted nearly a year, I asked John to undergo another heart scan. Score 2: 1383, a 16% increase.

I asked John to keep on going. Thankfully, he did manage to tolerate fish oil, niacin (though it required over a year just to get to a 1000 mg per day dose), and vitamin D. With all these efforts, he did reduce LDL to the 80-90 mg/dl range. Of course, John's unflagging optimism was crucial. He did express his occasional anxiety over his heart scan score, but dealt with it in a logical, philosophical way. He understood that there was no role for prophylactic stents or bypass, and he accepted that much of his program rested on his ability to adhere to the strategies we advised.

Another year later, a 3rd heart scan: 1210, a 12% reduction.

I'm very proud of John and his success. When you think about it, he succeeded in conquering heart disease with some very simple tools, minus statin drugs. It can be done, but requires consistency and patience--and an optimistic outlook.

Comments (5) -

  • katkarma

    10/12/2007 6:37:00 PM |

    I try to follow your regimen of Fish Oil, Vitamin D, niacin and eat oat bran w/flax seeds also, but I use whey protein shakes in the morning because of the taste.   Is  this amount of soy really helping to lower LDL?  Is whey protein ok to use?

  • Dr. Davis

    10/13/2007 1:51:00 AM |

    Yes, I believe whey is fine.

    The LDL-reducing effect of soy is very modest, usually no more than 10 mg/dl. I like it because of the protein that permits low-glycemic index foods to be created with it. I also grew up with soy products since I was a kid and am very comfortable with its many forms.

  • wccaguy

    10/13/2007 2:17:00 AM |

    Just to follow up on katkarma's question...

    Is there any reason to use soy protein rather than whey protein other than that modest LDL lowering effect?

    Any reason not to use whey protein as a surrogate for soy protein?

  • Dr. Davis

    10/16/2007 10:52:00 PM |

    To my knowledge, whey protein is fine, though without direct effects on such things as LDL/small LDL.

  • Scott Parrish

    10/17/2007 1:09:00 PM |

    Kaayla Daniel, in her book "The Whole Soy Story," makes the best for avoiding soy unless fermented. Fermented options including natto, miso, tempeh, but NOT soy protein isolate, tofu, soy milk and other popular soy forms. Problems with soy include estrogenic activity, certain mineral absorption problems, thyroid problems, increased risk for certain cancers.

Loading