Should you take Plavix?

A question I get fairly frequently nowadays is, "Should I take Plavix?"

For the few of you who've managed to miss the mass advertising campaign for this drug on TV, USA Today, etc., Plavix is a platelet-blocking drug, known chemically as clopidogrel, that "thins" the blood and helps prevent blood clot formation in coronary arteries and carotid arteries, thus potentially reducing heart attack and stroke risk.

What if you have a heart scan score of, say, 450--should you take Plavix?

In general, no. First of all, aspirin and Plavix (generally taken together, since the effect of Plavix is incremental to that of aspirin) only block blood clot formation. They have no effect whatsoever on the rate of plaque growth. Aspirin and Plavix will neither slow it or increase it.

What they do is when a plaque ruptures like a little volcano and exposes its internal contents (inflammatory cells, fat, etc.--like a raw wound), a blood clot forms on top of the ruptured surface. If the clot is big enough, it can occlude the vessel and causes heart attack. Or, if it's a carotid artery, debris from the clot can break off and find its way headward to the artery controlling your speech or memory center. Aspirin and Plavix simply help inhibit clot formation once a plaque ruptures. That's it.

Interestingly, if you view any of Sanofi Aventis' commercials for Plavix, you'd think they came up with a cure for heart disease. It ain't true.

When is Plavix helpful? It's clearly an advantage after someone receives a coronary stent, drug-coated or uncoated;, after coronary bypass, particularly if certain metal punch devices are used to create the grafts in the aorta; and during and after heart attack. These are all situations in which blood clot formation is a forceful process. Blocking it helps.

In general, in asymptomatic people with positive heart scan scores at any level, we do not recommend taking Plavix. The Plavix people are extremely aggressive pushing their drug (hang around any medical office and see!) and, I believe, have gone overboard in promoting its benefits. Rarely, in someone with a very high heart scan score, say 2000 or more, we'll use Plavix for a period of a few months until lipids/lipoproteins and other risk measures are addressed, just as an added safety measure. But, in general, the great majority of people with some heart scan score or another do not receive it and I don't believe that they should.

As always, look beyond the marketing. The purpose of marketing is to increase profits, not to educate.

Comments (2) -

  • Anonymous

    1/27/2009 5:11:00 AM |

    My father died of a heart attack on January 16, 2009 while taking Plavix. He has been taking this drug for a couple of years, and I believe that it killed him.

    Pharmaceutical companies, such as Bristol-Myers Squibb and Sanofi Aventis, who knowing sell medications which kill the people who are taking it should be criminally prosecuted!

    I’m mad as hell, and I’m looking for legal advice concerning this medication and how it may have caused my father’s death.

  • buy jeans

    11/3/2010 2:21:37 PM |

    When is Plavix helpful? It's clearly an advantage after someone receives a coronary stent, drug-coated or uncoated;, after coronary bypass, particularly if certain metal punch devices are used to create the grafts in the aorta; and during and after heart attack. These are all situations in which blood clot formation is a forceful process. Blocking it helps.

Loading
Don't neglect your magnesium

Don't neglect your magnesium

Magnesium is kind of boring. So most people don't pay too much attention to it.

Magnesium can be important, however. I saw an interesting phenomenon recently. A type I diabetic patient of mine (that is, an adult who developed diabetes as a child), Mitch, was experiencing wide swings in blood sugar: low low's and very high high's (300-400 mg/dl). Mitch's magnesium was only marginally low at 2.0 mEq/L. (Ranges for normal magnesium blood levels are usually 1.3–2.1 mEq/L or 0.65–1.05 mmol/L.) Note that Mitch's blood levels fall within "normal." I do not agree with these "normal" ranges. I shoot for 2.1 to 2.4 mEq/L, which I think is the truly normal range.

In addition to eating plenty of raw nuts and green vegetables, Mitch began supplementing magnesium with magnesium citrate, 200 mg twice a day (our preferred supplement form). He reported that the wide swings in blood sugar were nearly eliminated.

Mitch's dramatic benefit is just a great illustration of how magnesium can help control blood sugar metabolism. A type I diabetic is more sensitive to the effects, but anyone with type II (adult) diabetes, metabolic syndrome, or just a slightly high blood sugar could benefit from magnesium supplementation.

There's a number of ways to accomplish getting sufficient magnesium in your daily regimen. Track Your Plaque members, Be sure to read:


Your water may be killing you at
http://www.cureality.com/library/fl_03-002magnesium.asp

Magnesium: Water to the rescue! at http://www.cureality.com/library/fl_03-010magnesium2.asp

Comments (3) -

  • magnesium_matters@comcast.net

    3/4/2007 10:01:00 PM |

    1) magnesium increases insulin sensitivity, the ability of the liver and large muscles to sequester sugar in response to insulin. that isn't necessarily a problem in insulin-dependent diabetics but this one is an adult and could be showing some type 2 symptoms (insulin resistance.  Depending on serm magnesium as a guide to deficiency will miss the majority.  insulin dependent and type 2 diabetics lose magnesium every time their sugar rises.  serum magnesium is a notoriously poor guide to magnesium status.  may authorities in the field recomend prophylaxis in any magnesiu-wasting state. 3) citrate is a large molecule.  magnesium citrate is three fourths citrate.  citrate supplementation increases the absorption of magnesium slightly (over oxide) but it also increase the absorption and tissue uptake of aluminum and lead.  i prefer oxide.

    magnesium_matters@comcast.net

  • x.ds

    11/22/2009 1:04:07 AM |

    Why would the benefit of magnesium citrate to type-1 diabetes be due to magnesium and not to citrate ??? Citrate is a good metal chelator. It will lower pancreatic oxidative stress allowing better pancreatic function. Type-1 diabetes like other autoimmune diseases (such as arthritis) is due to oxidative stress and free metals are a major cause of oxidative stress in the body (the first cause by far however is drugs). In laboratory animals for example type-1 diabetes can be generated by giving them cereals and soy, two kinds of food that cause high level of oxidative stress. Link: http://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:-4wvlFXUWaMJ:www.nzfsa.govt.nz/policy-law/projects/a1-a2-milk/a1-a2-report.pdf+A+cereal-based+diet+%28mainly+wheat,+corn+and+soybean%29+called+NIH-07+is+often+used+as+a+standard+diabetes-promoting+diet&hl=en&sig=AHIEtbS5jjkwib8XkUB7hz_-flR3NbgY1g (search the second occurrence of "wheat").

  • buy jeans

    11/2/2010 9:15:37 PM |

    In addition to eating plenty of raw nuts and green vegetables, Mitch began supplementing magnesium with magnesium citrate, 200 mg twice a day (our preferred supplement form). He reported that the wide swings in blood sugar were nearly eliminated.

Loading